I want to be very clear that I have absolutely no shade for men who go on to earn doctoral degrees. MD, PhD, JD, DMD, PharmD… the list goes on. And if you happen to possess both an MD and a PhD? Baby…. There is something deeply attractive about a man who has voluntarily committed that many years of his life to academic suffering. I appreciate intellectual ambition, particularly when it comes with the discipline required to see something difficult through to completion. Although I must confess there is one academic discipline that will forever receive a raised eyebrow from me: theology. Please do not introduce yourself as Doctor Reverend and insist upon me using the appropriate titles when the letters behind your name are ThD or DMin without expecting a few follow-up questions first. Naturally, I would be interested in your dissertation. What did you research? What conclusions did you reach? And, perhaps most importantly, what have we learned that might be useful to the rest of humanity? Because after several thousand years of religious scholarship, we are somehow still managing to have religious wars. I am simply curious about when we might begin seeing some practical results.
Now, having followed my rather elaborate educational standards through middle school, college, and graduate school, you may reasonably expect this story to conclude with the introduction of my husband, a distinguished scholar whose academic credentials finally satisfied the requirements I had spent years developing. Fortunately, my husband does not have a doctorate. By the time I met him, I had begun reconsidering the entire premise of my youthful dating philosophy. My father, for example, held both an MD and an OD. He was a spectacular father, but marriage revealed a rather different set of abilities. I had the unusual privilege of watching a man excel beautifully in his academic pursuits, while struggling profoundly in his marital relationship. Which taught me that intelligence, professional accomplishment, and the ability to be a good husband were not necessarily related. Meanwhile, my student loan balance was growing at an alarming rate, and I was becoming considerably more interested in whether a gentleman had a job than whether he had pursued graduate education. Preferably a job that paid actual money. Education remained an excellent investment, but I was discovering that the returns varied considerably.
Now, I can already hear someone accusing me of being a gold digger, which I find terribly amusing considering how little gold there was to dig for among the young men I encountered during the Great Recession in Alabama. I was not searching for wealth. But I was learning to recognize potential. A man could defend a dissertation and still be incapable of having a difficult conversation. He could graduate from law school and somehow turn every disagreement into a courtroom proceeding. And a man with an MBA might simply have acquired an expensive vocabulary for explaining why he was always right. I had spent much of my youth believing that education was evidence of the kind of man someone would become. What I had not understood was that education could tell me what a man had studied, but not necessarily what he valued. Looking back, I have to laugh at myself. At eleven, I was eliminating boys based on their college plans. By eighteen, I had developed a graduate-student exception. By twenty, I had practically established an admissions committee for potential boyfriends. I was evaluating transcripts when I should have been evaluating character. Fortunately, I figured this out before I started requesting letters of recommendation from former girlfriends.
Which brings me to David. I was twenty-one when I met my husband, and I remain convinced that the good Lord gave me something resembling an out-of-body experience that evening. I looked at him and somehow knew he was the one. When David and I began dating, he was a college graduate earning less money than I did as a nurse. But what interested me was not his salary. It was the way he thought about his future. He recognized that he wanted to do more professionally and was willing to make the sacrifices required to pursue it. After we became boyfriend and girlfriend, he returned to school to earn a second bachelor’s degree in computer science. He started over in a new field, worked his way up, and eventually made his way into Silicon Valley and big tech. Today, he is building again in the startup world. Over the years, I have watched him take risks, develop new skills, and pursue opportunities neither of us could have imagined when we first met. His education certainly opened doors, but his ambition, determination, and willingness to keep learning were what carried him through them. And perhaps my favorite part of our marriage is that neither of us has had to remain the person we were in 2010. We have had the privilege of growing into new versions of ourselves together, occasionally with considerably more confidence than evidence that our plans would work.
And so, after four essays and a rather unnecessary amount of consideration given to the educational qualifications of men, I find myself returning to the little girl who started this entire investigation. I still believe education matters. I still admire intellectual curiosity, ambition, and the discipline required to accomplish difficult things. But I no longer believe that the letters behind a man’s name tell me everything I need to know about him. At eleven, I thought I needed a man who planned to attend college. At eighteen, I thought graduate school was evidence of superior judgment. By twenty-one, I had finally begun to understand that the most important qualities in a partner were not things a university could award. As it turns out, I did not need a man who had already accomplished everything. I needed one who was willing to keep learning, growing, and occasionally entertaining my rather ambitious ideas. I married David, retired my admissions committee, and have spent the years since discovering that building a life together is considerably more interesting than evaluating someone’s résumé. Although I must confess, after all these years, I still have one nonnegotiable academic requirement: the man must be willing to admit when I am right. Unfortunately, despite his two bachelor’s degrees and a successful career in technology, David remains committed to independent research on that subject.
Lesson learned. Dissertation pending.
Always Have, Always Will ~ Kalie

Leave a Reply